Research Article| Volume 51, ISSUE 4, P451-463, March 2015

Download started.


Accelerated partial breast irradiation using intensity-modulated radiotherapy versus whole breast irradiation: 5-year survival analysis of a phase 3 randomised controlled trial

Published:January 17, 2015DOI:



      Accelerated partial breast irradiation (APBI) has been introduced as an alternative treatment method for selected patients with early stage breast cancer (BC). Intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) has the theoretical advantage of a further increase in dose conformity compared with three-dimensional techniques, with more normal tissue sparing. The aim of this randomised trial is to compare the local recurrence and survival of APBI using the IMRT technique after breast-conserving surgery to conventional whole-breast irradiation (WBI) in early stage BC.


      This study was performed at the University of Florence (Florence, Italy). Women aged more than 40 years affected by early BC, with a maximum pathological tumour size of 25 mm, were randomly assigned in a 1:1 ratio to receive either WBI or APBI using IMRT. Patients in the APBI arm received a total dose of 30 Gy to the tumour bed in five daily fractions. The WBI arm received 50 Gy in 25 fractions, followed by a boost on the tumour bed of 10 Gy in five fractions. The primary end-point was occurrence of ipsilateral breast tumour recurrences (IBTRs); the main analysis was by intention-to-treat. This trial is registered with, number NCT02104895.


      A total of 520 patients were randomised (260 to external WBI and 260 to APBI with IMRT) between March 2005 and June 2013. At a median follow-up of 5.0 years (Interquartile Range (IQR) 3.4–7.0), the IBTR rate was 1.5% (three cases) in the APBI group (95% confidence interval (CI) 0.1–3.0) and in the WBI group (three cases; 95% CI 0.0–2.8). No significant difference emerged between the two groups (log rank test p = 0.86). We identified seven deaths in the WBI group and only one in the APBI group (p = 0.057). The 5-year overall survival was 96.6% for the WBI group and 99.4% for the APBI group. The APBI group presented significantly better results considering acute (p = 0.0001), late (p = 0.004), and cosmetic outcome (p = 0.045).


      To our knowledge, this is the first randomised study using the IMRT technique for APBI delivery. No significant difference in terms of IBTR and overall survival was observed between the two arms. APBI displayed a significantly better toxicity profile.


      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'


      Subscribe to European Journal of Cancer
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect


        • Veronesi U.
        • Cascinelli N.
        • Mariani L.
        • et al.
        Twenty-year follow-up of a randomized study comparing breast-conserving surgery with radical mastectomy for early breast cancer.
        N Engl J Med. 2002; 347: 1227-1232
        • Fisher B.
        • Anderson S.
        • Bryant J.
        • et al.
        Twenty-year follow-up of a randomized trial comparing total mastectomy, lumpectomy, and lumpectomy plus irradiation for the treatment of invasive breast cancer.
        N Engl J Med. 2002; 347: 1233-1241
        • Liljegren G.
        • Holmberg L.
        • Bergh J.
        • et al.
        10-Year results after sector resection with or without postoperative radiotherapy for stage I breast cancer: a randomized trial.
        J Clin Oncol. 1999; 17: 2326-2333
        • Arriagada R.
        • Le M.G.
        • Rochard F.
        • et al.
        Conservative treatment versus mastectomy in early breast cancer: patterns of failure with 15 years of follow-up data. Institut Gustave-Roussy Breast Cancer Group.
        J Clin Oncol. 1996; 14: 1558-1564
        • Vicini F.A.
        • Baglan K.L.
        • Kestin L.L.
        • et al.
        Accelerated treatment of breast cancer.
        J Clin Oncol. 2001; 19: 1993-2001
        • Greenup R.A.
        • Camp M.S.
        • Taghian A.G.
        • et al.
        Cost comparison of radiation treatment options after lumpectomy for breast cancer.
        Ann Surg Oncol. 2012; 19: 3275-3281
        • Bensaleh S.
        • Bezak E.
        • Borg M.
        Review of MammoSite brachytherapy: advantages, disadvantages and clinical outcomes.
        Acta Oncol. 2008; 22: 1-8
        • Veronesi U.
        • Orecchia R.
        • Maisonneuve P.
        • et al.
        Intraoperative radiotherapy versus external radiotherapy for early breast cancer (ELIOT): a randomised controlled equivalence trial.
        Lancet Oncol. 2013; 14: 1269-1277
        • Mukesh M.B.
        • Barnett G.C.
        • Wilkinson J.S.
        • et al.
        Randomized controlled trial of intensity-modulated radiotherapy for early breast cancer: 5-year results confirm superior overall cosmesis.
        J Clin Oncol. 2013; 31: 4488-4495
        • Klepczyk L.C.
        • Keene K.S.
        • De Los Santos J.F.
        Accelerated partial breast irradiation for early-stage breast cancer: controversies and current indications for use.
        Curr Treat Options Oncol. 2013; 14: 51-65
        • Smith B.D.
        • Arthur D.W.
        • Buchholz T.A.
        • et al.
        Accelerated partial breast irradiation consensus statement from the American Society for Radiation Oncology (ASTRO).
        Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2009; 74: 987-1001
        • Polgár C.
        • Van Limbergen E.
        • Pötter R.
        • et al.
        Patient selection for accelerated partial-breast irradiation (APBI) after breast-conserving surgery: recommendations of the Groupe Européen de Curiethérapie-European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology (GEC-ESTRO) breast cancer working group based on clinical evidence (2009).
        Radiother Oncol. 2010; 94: 264-273
        • Livi L.
        • Buonamici F.B.
        • Simontacchi G.
        • et al.
        Accelerated partial breast irradiation with IMRT: new technical approach and interim analysis of acute toxicity in a phase III randomized clinical trial.
        Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2010; 77: 509-515
        • Hammond M.E.
        • Hayes D.F.
        • Wolff A.C.
        • et al.
        American society of clinical oncology/college of American Pathologists guideline recommendations for immunohistochemical testing of estrogen and progesterone receptors in breast cancer.
        J Oncol Pract. 2010; 6: 195-197
        • Bouzubar N.
        • Walker K.J.
        • Griffiths K.
        • et al.
        Ki67 immunostaining in primary breast cancer: pathological and clinical associations.
        Br J Cancer. 1989; 59: 943-947
        • DeCensi A.
        • Guerrieri-Gonzaga A.
        • Gandini S.
        • et al.
        Prognostic significance of Ki-67 labeling index after short-term presurgical tamoxifen in women with ER-positive breast cancer.
        Ann Oncol. 2011; 22: 582-587
        • Munzone E.
        • Botteri E.
        • Sciandivasci A.
        • et al.
        Prognostic value of Ki-67 labeling index in patients with node-negative, triple-negative breast cancer.
        Breast Cancer Res Treat. 2012; 134: 277-282
        • Dowsett M.
        • Nielsen T.O.
        • A’Hern R.
        • et al.
        Assessment of Ki67 in breast cancer: recommendations from the International Ki67 in Breast Cancer Working Group.
        J Natl Cancer Inst. 2011; 103: 1656-1664
        • Elston C.W.
        • Ellis I.O.
        Pathological prognostic factors in breast cancer: I. The value of histological grade in breast cancer—Experience from a large study with long-term follow-up.
        Histopathology. 2002; 41: 151-152
        • Goldhirsch A.
        • Wood W.C.
        • Coates A.S.
        • et al.
        Strategies for subtypes—dealing with the diversity of breast cancer: highlights of the St. Gallen International Expert Consensus on the Primary Therapy of Early Breast Cancer 2011.
        Ann Oncol. 2011; 22: 1736-1747
        • Cox J.D.
        • Stetz J.
        • Pajak T.F.
        Toxicity criteria of the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) and the European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer (EORTC).
        Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1995; 31: 1341-1346
        • Trombetta M.
        • Julian T.B.
        • Kim Y.
        • et al.
        The allegheny general modification of the Harvard Breast Cosmesis Scale for the retreated breast.
        Oncology. 2009; 23: 954-956
        • Belkacemi Y.
        • Bourgier C.
        • Kramar A.
        • et al.
        SHARE: a French multicenter phase III trial comparing accelerated partial irradiation versus standard or hypofractionated whole breast irradiation in breast cancer patients at low risk of local recurrence.
        Clin Adv Hematol Oncol. 2013; 11: 76-83
        • Vaidya J.S.
        • Joseph D.J.
        • Tobias J.S.
        • et al.
        Targeted intraoperative radiotherapy versus whole breast radiotherapy for breast cancer (TARGIT-A trial): an international, prospective, randomised, non-inferiority phase 3 trial.
        Lancet. 2010; 376: 91-102
        • Vaidya J.S.
        • Wenz F.
        • Bulsara M.
        • et al.
        Risk-adapted targeted intraoperative radiotherapy versus whole-breast radiotherapy for breast cancer: 5-year results for local control and overall survival from the TARGIT-A randomised trial.
        Lancet. 2014; 383: 603-613
        • Blamey R.W.
        • Bates T.
        • Chetty U.
        • et al.
        Radiotherapy or tamoxifen after conserving surgery for breast cancers of excellent prognosis: British Association of Surgical Oncology (BASO) II trial.
        Eur J Cancer. 2013; 49: 2294-2302
        • Morgan D.A.
        • Bates T.
        • Duffy S.W.
        • et al.
        Addendum to BASOII trial report.
        Eur J Cancer. 2014; 50: 2517-2518
        • Lei R.Y.
        • Leonard C.E.
        • Howell K.T.
        • et al.
        Four-year clinical update from a prospective trial of accelerated partial breast intensity-modulated radiotherapy (APBIMRT).
        Breast Cancer Res Treat. 2013; 140: 119-133
        • Lewin A.A.
        • Derhagopian R.
        • Saigal K.
        • et al.
        Accelerated partial breast irradiation is safe and effective using intensity-modulated radiation therapy in selected early-stage breast cancer.
        Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2012; 82: 2104-2110
        • Bergom C.
        • Prior P.
        • Kainz K.
        • et al.
        A phase I/II study piloting accelerated partial breast irradiation using CT-guided intensity modulated radiation therapy in the prone position.
        Radiother Oncol. 2013; 108: 215-219
        • Liss A.L.
        • Ben-David M.A.
        • Jagsi R.
        • et al.
        Decline of cosmetic outcomes following accelerated partial breast irradiation using intensity modulated radiation therapy: results of a single-institution prospective clinical trial.
        Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2014; 89: 96-102
        • Olivotto I.A.
        • Whelan T.J.
        • Parpia S.
        • et al.
        Interim cosmetic and toxicity results from RAPID: a randomized trial of accelerated partial breast irradiation using three-dimensional conformal external beam radiation therapy.
        J Clin Oncol. 2013; 31: 4038-4045
        • Yarnold J.
        • Bentzen S.M.
        • Coles C.
        • et al.
        Hypofractionated whole-breast radiotherapy for women with early breast cancer: myths and realities.
        Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2011; 79: 1-9
        • Michalski A.
        • Atyeo J.
        • Cox J.
        • Rinks M.
        Inter- and intra-fraction motion during radiation therapy to the whole breast in the supine position: a systematic review.
        J Med Imaging Radiat Oncol. 2012; 56: 499-509
        • Bortfeld T.
        • Jokivarsi K.
        • Goitein M.
        • Kung J.
        • Jiang S.B.
        Effects of intra-fraction motion on IMRT dose delivery: statistical analysis and simulation.
        Phys Med Biol. 2002; 47: 2203-2220
        • Shah C.
        • Lanni T.B.
        • Saini H.
        • et al.
        Cost-efficacy of acceleration partial-breast irradiation compared with whole-breast irradiation.
        Breast Cancer Res Treat. 2013; 138: 127-135
        • Haviland J.S.
        • Owen J.R.
        • Dewar J.A.
        • et al.
        The UK Standardisation of Breast Radiotherapy (START) trials of radiotherapy hypofractionation for treatment of early breast cancer: 10-year follow-up results of two randomised controlled trials.
        Lancet Oncol. 2013; 14: 1086-1094
        • Agrawal R.K.
        • Alhasso A.
        • et al.
        • FAST Trialists group
        First results of the randomised UK FAST Trial of radiotherapy hypofractionation for treatment of early breast cancer (CRUKE/04/015).
        Radiother Oncol. 2011; 100: 93-100
        • Whelan T.J.
        • Pignol J.P.
        • Levine M.N.
        • et al.
        Long-term results of hypofractionated radiation therapy for breast cancer.
        N Engl J Med. 2010; 362: 513-520
        • Dodwell D.J.
        • Dyker K.
        • Brown J.
        • et al.
        A randomised study of whole-breast vs tumour-bed irradiation after local excision and axillary dissection for early breast cancer.
        Clin Oncol (R Coll Radiol). 2005; 17: 618-622
        • Ribeiro G.G.
        • Magee B.
        • Swindell R.
        • Harris M.
        • Banerjee S.S.
        The Christie Hospital breast conservation trial: an update at 8 years from inception.
        Clin Oncol (R Coll Radiol). 1993; 5: 278-283
        • Lehman M.
        • Hickey B.E.
        • Francis D.P.
        • See A.M.
        Partial breast irradiation for early breast cancer.
        Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2014; 6: CD007077

      Linked Article

      • Authors reply
        European Journal of CancerVol. 51Issue 11
        • Preview
          We appreciate Drs. Bhattacharjee’s and Chakraborty’s comments on our phase 3 trial comparing whole breast irradiation (WBI) to accelerated partial breast irradiation (APBI) using IMRT technique for low risk breast cancer (BC) patients [1].
        • Full-Text
        • PDF